Contender or Pretender?
April 16th, 2008 by timpetBy Timothy Petropoulos
We see it all the time. Unrecognized players starting hot and everyone thinking that they are the secret to their fantasy championship.
Even though most falter, some are the fantasy in fact the fantasy savior. Lets look into some guys that have started off quickly and decide…Is this guy going to make you a Contender or is he just a Pretender?
Pretender
Nate McLouth (Pit - OF) - Although Nate is having a fantastic start to the season, he is a little to good to be true. This career .245 hitter with just 25 career HR’s is currently killing the ball at a .383 clip including 2 jacks, 14 RBI’s and a 11 runs. One of the main reasons that McLouth can’t keep these numbers up is because the of the Pirates line-up. Career platoon players like Xavier Nady and Ryan Doumit are driving McLouth in at an amazing rate but that will not last. McLouth will get you some runs, some steals, and some HR’s but nothing to merit him having a starting spot in a mixed-league roster after April.
Gabe Kapler (Mil - OF) -This guy could be the real deal, unfortunately, he won’t get the chance to be. CF Mike Cameron is serving a 25 game suspension for enfedimine use and will be the starting Center Fielder when he comes back. Kapler, who is used to being well traveled (went from playing in Japan, to playing for the Red Sox, to managing the Red Sox single-A affiliate…ALL LAST SEASON), will travel to at least one more spot before the the season ends. The bench.
Justin Upton (Ari - OF) -The youngest player in the league (20 years old) is having a season that screams Ken Griffey Jr. all over again, and he will be the real deal one day. But right now, sell high on Justin. His 5 HR’s and 12 RBI’s are nice in the early season, but he has already struck out 12 times and shown (as most young players do) an inability to hit a good breaking ball. Once pitcher figure him out, he’ll fall back down to earth. A 20/20 season is not out of his reach though.
Contender
Mark Reynolds (Ari - 3B) -Unlike Justin Upton, Reynolds is a little older and a little more seasoned. This kid is the real deal. With a combination of a sweet power stroke (5 HR’s in 50 AB’s), improving eye (.368 on-base up from his career .351), experience (endured a streak of 7 consecutive K’s last season and fought through it), and line-up positioning (Bats 4th or 5th in the middle of a solid line-up) this guy should be in your starting line-up everyday (unless you have an elite 3B like Wright, Ramirez, or C. Jones).
Zach Greinke (KC - SP) -Finally! Finally! I have been waiting for this guy for 3 years to realize his potential. He has a 92-94 MPH fastball, a never-gets-there change-up and a wicked curve. This all translates to a 3-0 record, .75 ERA, and a .92 WHIP. The strike-outs are low (9 K’s in 24 IP’s) but when they get where they should be this guy will be an elite starter in this league. Expect 15-17 wins for Geinke with an improved Royals team behind him.
Ryan Church (Mets - OF) - Ryan is getting his shot, and he is taking advantage of it. For the first time in his career Ryan is starting full-time and batting 6th in a line-up littered with stars. Expect 25-30 HR’s, 85-95 RBI’s, 70-80 Runs, and 5-10 Steals.